Net Unrealized Appreciation | Episode 3

March 6, 2025

Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) and its planning details. It covers the factors to consider when deciding whether to elect NUA treatment for employer securities within a retirement plan. The video also explains the tax implications of retirement accounts versus taxable brokerage accounts and the specific requirements for NUA treatment, such as triggering events and the lump-sum distribution rule.

Transcript

0:05
So, in this week’s episode, we want to continue the discussion around the NUA, which is net unrealized appreciation. This week’s episode will expand a little

0:14
more on the planning details for NUA. The analysis on how much, if any, of the employer securities within a

0:22
retirement plan to elect NUA treatment is a unique decision for each person, based on projected annual

0:30
retirement income needs, projected future marginal tax rates, and also estate planning considerations. The tax deferral within a

0:39
retirement account is a powerful accelerant for wealth accumulation, as both dividends and capital gains are not

0:46
taxed when received each year, as they would be in a taxable brokerage account. However, the tax deferral benefit

0:54
comes at a cost tradeoff. Almost every dollar distributed from a pre-tax retirement account will be taxed at

1:01
ordinary income tax rates. These rates are almost always higher than those on dividends and capital gains. While within

1:10
a taxable brokerage account, both dividends and capital gains generally receive favorable tax

1:17
treatment, but they are nonetheless taxed when received, which can reduce overall returns due to the taxes owed on

1:25
these. As mentioned in last week’s episode, distributions only qualify for NUA treatment if completed after the triggering event, which there are

1:34
really four of them: separation from service, reaching retirement age of 59 and a half, death, or

1:41
disability. In addition, shares of employer securities for the NUA must be moved in kind to a taxable brokerage

1:49
account. You cannot sell the securities within the retirement plan, then move cash to a brokerage account and purchase

1:57
the same shares at that point. This wouldn’t qualify for the NUA benefit. Another major point is

2:04
that the retirement plan must be emptied within the calendar year as a lump-sum distribution. So, let’s say you are

2:12
planning to retire in November or December of a future year. We strongly recommend you don’t initiate any

2:19
distributions until the following January, and the reason for that is, if there is a delay in processing the transaction, you run the risk of the

2:27
retirement plan not being fully liquidated before December 31st, which will negate the NUA treatment and can

2:35
leave you with a large tax liability on the full amount of the distribution. So, until our next episode,

2:42
keep searching for opportunities to enhance your wealth.

Keep Learning

Scroll to Top